A man in a dark coat seen from behind on a subway platform at night, standing still as a train blurs past.
Field Notes · Anxiety & Stress

Rumination: Why Your Mind Keeps Looping, and How to Stop

You have replayed the conversation for the fortieth time, and it has not gotten better. Rumination is that loop: going over what went wrong, why it went wrong, and what it says about you, again and again, without getting anywhere. Everyone does some version of it after a hard day. Rumination becomes a problem when the loop keeps running for days, crowds out sleep, and never arrives at an answer.

Three things are worth knowing before anything else, whatever brought you here. Rumination is common: a large proportion of people ruminate at some point, and most people who experience rumination do not know there is a name for it. It is a habit of thinking, not a flaw in your character. And it can be interrupted, in specific ways, by you and by a therapist.

What is rumination?

Researchers have defined rumination in slightly different ways over the years. The definition that holds up is this: rumination involves repetitive thinking about distress, its possible causes, and its consequences, with the attention turned inward and the focus on one’s feelings rather than on the problem. Researchers also separate trait rumination, the habit, from state rumination, the episode you are in tonight. It is a way of responding to distress, and the behaviors that follow it, withdrawing, replaying, avoiding, are part of the pattern. The word comes from cows, who chew the same mouthful again and again. In people, the mouthful is a mistake, a loss, a comment, or a depressed mood, and the chewing is mental.

Psychologists first described rumination in the early 1990s as one way people respond to feeling sad. In that account, now called response styles theory, two people can start with the same depressed mood. One turns inward and analyzes it from every angle, weighing all the aspects of why. The other does something that takes their mind elsewhere. The first person tends to stay low longer, and the response, not the mood itself, is what keeps it going.

Later work found that rumination has two parts that behave differently. One is brooding: moody comparison, self-blame, “why do I always react this way.” The other, in contrast, is reflection: turning a problem over to understand it. In a community sample measured twice, a year apart, brooding was the part tied to later depression.

Reflection, on its own, mostly was not. That distinction matters for you, because it means the goal is never to stop thinking. The goal is to stop the brooding type of ruminative thinking, and to keep the kind that reaches an answer.

One more clarification, because the word has a second meaning. Rumination syndrome, sometimes called rumination disorder, is a digestive condition in which food comes back up after eating. It has nothing to do with the thinking pattern this article covers. If that is what you are looking for, your doctor is the right place to start.

What rumination looks like

The research word is “rumination.” Ruminating thoughts, in real life, come in a variety of shapes, and the themes repeat. Here are three situations people describe most often, and in each one the length of the loop is the problem, not its subject.

The replayed conversation

You said something in a meeting that landed wrong, or you think it did. On the walk to the Metro you are already back in the room. By evening you have run the moment dozens of times, each time with a slightly different reading of the other person’s face, trying to recall exactly what they said. You remember every pause. The question underneath is “why did I say that,” and no number of replays answers it.

The middle-of-the-night audit

You wake and the mind opens a file. It starts with today and works backward: the thing you did not finish, the friend you did not call, the pattern that proves something about you. The question is “what is wrong with me.” It feels like honesty. In reality it produces nothing you can use in the morning, and it makes the night feel hopeless.

The breakup loop

After a relationship ends, the mind goes looking for the moment it could have gone differently. “If only I had” is the opening line. People can stay in this loop for months, and it is one reason moving on after a breakup takes longer for some than others.

The three have one thing in common, and it is the tell. The question never changes, and it never gets answered. That is what separates rumination from thinking a hard thing through: endless repetition, with no resolution ever reached.

Rumination vs. overthinking, worry, and intrusive thoughts

People use “overthinking” for all of these, and that is fine as an everyday word. The reason to separate them is that they respond to different things. Here is the rough map, and the table below is the short version.

Pattern What it asks Where it looks How it ends What it feels like
Rumination “Why did this happen? Why am I like this?” The past, and the self It does not. The question repeats. Heavy, sunk, stuck
Worry “What if it goes wrong?” The future When the thing happens, or is prevented Tense, wired, braced
Reflection “What happened, and what can I learn?” The past or the present With an answer, or a decision to let it go Neutral, sometimes sad, then done
Intrusive thoughts No question. An unwanted image or urge arrives on its own. Right now They pass if you do not fight them Alarming, “where did that come from”
Problem solving “What is the next step?” The present With an action Workable, even when the problem is hard

Rumination and worry are close cousins. Both are repetitive thoughts, both begin with negative thoughts, and many people do both. The difference, in a study that compared rumination and worry directly, is mostly direction: rumination points backward at negative events, losses, and failures, while anxious thoughts and worries point forward at what might go wrong. Researchers now group them under one name, repetitive negative thinking, because the same thinking style runs through many mental health conditions, from depression to anxiety disorders to insomnia.

If “overthinking” is the word you use, you are in the right place. Our post on simple ways to keep yourself from overthinking covers the everyday version. One more line is worth drawing. When the loop is a mental ritual you perform to cancel out a fear, such as reviewing whether you locked the door until the dread drops, that is closer to a compulsion, and OCD therapy is the better starting point.

Why your mind keeps looping back to negative thoughts

Nobody chooses to ruminate. Understanding why rumination runs is the first real step out of it, so here is the mechanism in plain terms.

Rumination starts with a trigger: a hard moment, one of life’s stressful events, a difficult conversation, or just a low mood on an ordinary afternoon. The attention turns inward. The mind starts asking abstract questions, the “why” kind. “Why does this keep happening to me?” “Why can’t I handle things like other people?” Those questions have no usable answer, so the mind keeps searching, spending time on a problem that does not move.

The searching makes the mood worse, and a worse mood pulls the attention inward again. The thought cycle spirals downward, and round it goes. The nature of the loop is that every lap feels like progress. Each lap represents another attempt at an answer, and none arrives.

A ring of 5 steps: A hard moment or a low mood, Turning inward, “Why?” questions with no answer, The mood sinks, Back to the start. Exits: A, Notice it and name it; B, Change the question from “why” to “what next”; C, Move your body or change the scene.A hard moment or alow moodTurning inward“Why?” questionswith no answerThe mood sinksBack to the startANotice it and name itBChange the questionfrom “why” to “whatnext”CMove your body orchange the scene
Rumination runs on its own once it is a habit. The three exits, A, B, and C, are explained in the section on how to stop ruminating.

Two findings from the research make the loop make sense.

The first is that the style of thinking matters more than the amount. In a review of many studies on repetitive thinking, going over a problem was beneficial when the thinking was concrete and specific, and harmful when it was abstract and evaluative. “What exactly happened, and what is one thing I could do next” is the same problem, thought about in a way that can finish. “Why am I such a failure” cannot finish, because no answer exists for it.

Why people ruminate even when it hurts

The second is that rumination feels useful. People keep ruminating because it feels like working on the problem, like figuring it out, like being responsible. It is a trap that feels like a tool, an attempt to solve a problem by thinking that has stopped being thinking. The idea that thinking harder will resolve it, despite the fact that it never has, is what keeps people in it.

A review of the mechanisms that keep rumination going describes it as a learned habit with roots in how you responded to stress long ago: with repetition it starts on its own, cued by a mood, a time of day, or a place, before you have decided anything. That is why “just stop thinking about it” fails. You cannot decide your way out of a habit. You can learn to recognize it earlier and respond in new ways, which is what the rest of this article is about. In what psychologists call control theories of the mind, rumination is what happens to a goal you cannot reach and cannot drop; the loop is the mind refusing to file it.

What causes rumination?

There is no single cause. Research suggests several factors behind rumination that stack, from what happens to you to what you learned to how you are built. None of them is essential on its own, and the causes and consequences feed each other: stress leads to rumination, and rumination leads to more stress. The influence runs both ways.

What happens to you. Stress and loss feed the loop, and so do the everyday stressors that never let up. In a study that followed 1,065 early adolescents, boys and girls, for seven months and 1,132 adults for a year, each assessed at the start and the end, stressful life events led to increases in rumination, and that increase helped explain why stress turned into anxiety symptoms in both groups, and into symptoms of depression in the adults, months later. The effect was observed at every age studied. That is the longitudinal evidence in one sentence, suggesting that rumination is one of the roads that can lead from a hard year to a hard mind.

What you learned. Rumination is a response style, and response styles are learned, often early, in adolescence or before. A parent who worried out loud, a family history of depression, a home where feelings had to be figured out alone, a childhood with more adversity than a child can process: all of these teach the mind to go inward and search, and they create a template the adult mind keeps using. In a review of 215 studies, people who had faced adversity as children were more prone to rumination as adults.

Who you are. Perfectionism and high standards keep the loop fed, because discrepancies between the standard and the result are material, and the perception of failure is quick. In three studies of mostly college students, perfectionists were more distressed partly because they brooded more. Self-criticism has its own version: attacking yourself in your head, repeatedly, overlaps with depressive rumination but is a pattern of its own. Low self-esteem makes every mistake feel like evidence, and a tendency toward negative self-talk gives the loop its script.

What you believe about it. Many people believe, somewhere underneath, that the loop is helpful. Believing that keeps it running, and it is the most important belief to revisit in therapy.

On gender differences: pooling 59 studies with 14,321 adults, women, compared with men, reported somewhat more rumination, and the extent of the difference was small. Men ruminate plenty. The finding describes averages and says nothing about individuals.

From Our Practice

You will sometimes hear us calling it hamster-wheeling: a lot of running, no distance covered. Nobody arrives saying “I ruminate.” People say they cannot stop thinking about something, and that stopping would feel like not caring. Often the loop has been doing the work of responsibility for years, and that is why it is so hard to put down.

Where rumination shows up: depression and anxiety, and beyond

Rumination is not a diagnosis. It is a pattern that many mental disorders share, which is reassuring in one way: the same tools help across all of them. What the loop is about changes with the condition, and so does the role rumination plays and the function it serves.

Depression and depressive symptoms

Depressive rumination circles the past and the self. It makes a depressed mood last longer and sink deeper, and it predicts what comes next. In a community study that interviewed people a year apart, those who ruminated more were more likely to develop a new episode of major depression over the following year, which is why researchers use it to predict who is at risk. Rumination is, in that sense, a significant risk factor for depression and other affective disorders, the clinical name for mood conditions, and not only a symptom of them.

If rumination and low mood are starting to stretch into weeks, our depression and anxiety therapy page is the place to read next.

Anxiety symptoms and worry

Anxiety rumination tends to face forward and loop back. A person with generalized anxiety disorder might worry about a meeting all week and then replay it for a week after. Worry runs on uncertainty; rumination, similarly repetitive, runs on regret. The same thinking style covers both halves, which is why both depression and anxiety respond to the same tools.

Social anxiety

After a party or a presentation, the mind reviews the tape, looking for the moment you embarrassed yourself. Researchers call this post-event processing, and it is one of the ways social anxiety keeps itself alive. We wrote about it in what therapies work for social anxiety, including why exposure alone is not the whole story.

OCD

In obsessive compulsive disorder, the loop can be a type of mental ritual: reviewing, checking, or arguing with a thought until the dread drops, for a while. It looks like rumination from the inside, and it is treated somewhat differently, which is why it gets its own page.

Trauma

After a traumatic event, an accident, an injury, an assault, rumination often takes the form of “why me” and “what should I have done.” That self-blame is one of the things that turns a terrible event into lasting symptoms, and it interferes with the emotional processing that recovery depends on.

Anger

Anger rumination replays the injustice and rehearses what you should have said. A measure built to study the relationship between rumination and anger found it tracks with hostility and keeps the anger alive long after the moment has passed.

Grief and breakups

Loss invites rumination, because the mind searches for a version of events in which the loss did not happen. Some of that searching is grief doing its work. When it goes on for months and starts to look like depression after a breakup, it has become rumination.

What rumination does to your mental and physical health over time

The loop has consequences, and they are worth naming plainly, not to frighten you but because the cost is the reason to interrupt it. The harm builds slowly, and it can affect more than mood.

Mood. Rumination makes low moods last longer and feel worse, and it magnifies negative emotions of every kind: sadness, shame, helplessness. When you feel sad and ruminate on it, the sadness lasts, and it crowds out happiness and interest in the things you used to enjoy. A review of many studies, the most cited in this field, found that rumination also raises the risk of depression and anxiety over time. Rumination does not just describe a bad mood. It extends it.

Thinking. The same review found that people caught in the loop solve problems less well and act on solutions less often. Negative thoughts get stickier, too, and the mind reaches for them first. Rumination feels like thinking hard. It crowds out the kind of thinking that leads anywhere, and it leaves little room for anything else, which is one reason people in the loop say they cannot hold onto what they just read: working memory is busy.

Sleep. Ruminating at night is one of the most reliable ways to lose sleep. In a questionnaire study of adults, people who ruminated more slept worse, and the associations held after taking their mood into account. If you keep waking in the middle of the night with the file open, rumination is probably part of it.

The body. Dwelling on stress keeps the body’s stress response switched on long after the stressful event has passed. A review of that research links the pattern, through those physiological pathways, to a slower return to baseline after stress and, over years, to wear on physical health, including inflammation, pain that lasts longer than it should, and a reduced ability to bounce back. Rumination may lead to physical symptoms before anyone names it as the cause.

Relationships. Rumination can push people away, because it is hard to be present while the file is open. It can also pull a friend in, so that two people loop together, a pattern researchers call co-rumination, and both feel worse by the end of the call. Social support helps most when it moves you toward a next step.

The brain. One sentence is enough here. Imaging studies of depression find that the network the brain uses for self-focused thought is unusually tightly linked to a region tied to low mood, and the link tracks how much a person ruminates. What that means for treatment is still uncertain: the imaging research is limited, the brain regions involved do many things, and the direction of cause is unknown.

Is the loop costing you sleep or your work?

If you have gone over it a hundred times and still feel stuck, therapy can help you step off the hamster wheel and back into your day.

Is this rumination? A few things people notice

This is not a test, and it does not diagnose anything. It is the set of signs people tend to notice once they have a word for the loop, and the list includes the ones we hear most. Read it gently; the aim is perspective, not a verdict.

  • When something goes wrong, your first thought is “why do I always do this.”
  • You think about a recent situation and wish it had gone better, and then you think about it again.
  • You go over your mistakes without getting to a decision about what to do.
  • The thinking has a time of day, often late at night or first thing in the morning.
  • Thinking about it feels responsible, and stopping feels like letting yourself off the hook.
  • Friends have started saying “you have told me this already.”

In most cases, a few of these on a bad week is being a person. Several of them, most days, for a few weeks, and the sign is clear: this is the pattern the article is about, and the next two sections are written for you. Researchers use a questionnaire called the Ruminative Responses Scale, part of a longer Response Styles Questionnaire, which measures two constructs, brooding and reflection, and scores their levels on separate subscales. You do not need one to know whether this is you.

From Our Practice

The first thing many people notice, once they start paying attention, is that the loop keeps a schedule. It opens at the same hour, in the same room, often the bedroom. That is useful information. A habit with a schedule can be met at the door.

How to stop ruminating

Most articles on this topic offer advice as a list of twelve coping strategies in no particular order. What follows is organized by distance from the moment, because, generally speaking, what helps in the next two minutes is different from what helps over a month, and where to begin depends on how far into the loop you are. The three exits from the loop figure, A, B, and C, are the first three steps.

Right now: a change of place or deep breathing for two minutes

A ring of 5 steps: A hard moment or a low mood, Turning inward, “Why?” questions with no answer, The mood sinks, Back to the start. Exits: A, ; B, ; C, .ABC
The three exits from the loop: A, name it; B, change the question; C, move.

A. Notice it and name it. Say “I’m ruminating,” out loud if you can, in your head if you cannot. The loop runs on automatic, like most patterns with years of practice behind them, and naming it is the simplest way to break the automatic part. It will not stop the thoughts. It changes your relationship to them, from being inside the loop to watching it run.

B. Change the question. From “why” to “what.” “What exactly happened?” “What is one thing I could do about it today?” If there is no “what,” that is also an answer: this is not a problem that thinking can solve right now, and rumination is running on a problem it cannot touch. This single shift, from abstract to concrete, is the core of the therapy built for rumination, and it is the most direct way to address the loop while it is running. If the question has an answer, the shift will generate a next step. If it does not, you have learned something true.

C. Move. Stand up, change rooms, go outside, play with the dog, walk to the end of the block or around the park. If you cannot leave, find a quiet space and breathe deeply for one minute with the exhale longer than the inhale. Deep breathing does not fix anything by itself. It helps because the loop is partly a body state, and the body is easier to change than the thought.

Distraction has a bad reputation, and it deserves a better one. Distraction techniques, a movie, a call, a task with your hands, are not avoidance when they are chosen, and they can help break a loop that will not break on its own. Distraction is also the oldest finding in this research: in the original response styles experiments, people who were asked to distract themselves from a low mood came out of it sooner than people who were asked to sit with it and analyze it. Choosing to distract yourself is a positive step, not an escape, and a good book or a long walk can provide exactly the pause the mind needs, as long as you come back to the problem when you are capable of thinking about it concretely.

Today

Write it down once, fully, and then close the notebook. A journal page holds the thoughts so you do not have to save them in your head. Then run the one routine that reliably turns a loop into an action. It works by breaking the problem into smaller parts.

1

Name the problem in one specific sentence

Not “my career is a mess.” Instead: “I have not replied to the message from my manager about the deadline.” Specific problems have next steps. Abstract ones have verdicts.
2

Pick the smallest next action

Something that takes under twenty minutes. Reply to the message. Look up the one number. Draft the first sentence. If the smallest action is still too big, it is not small enough yet.
3

Do it within twenty-four hours

Set a time and do it then, not when you feel ready, to ensure it happens. The loop thrives on the gap between knowing and doing.
4

Notice what happened, specifically, and let that be the end of it for today

“I replied. She said Thursday is fine.” That is a complete thought. It can finish, which is the whole point.

Then engage someone else, with one rule. Ask a friend or family member to help you get to a next step, not to go around the loop with you. Most people are glad to be given the job, and the offer of a next step is worth more than sympathy.

The challenges that keep you up are rarely as unsolvable as they look late at night. In addition, do some physical activity, anything, ideally outside and ideally before dark. Exercising is one of the few things that reliably changes both the mood and the body state at once.

This month

Learn your rumination triggers. Rumination keeps a schedule and a map: the hour before bed, the phone in bed, the drive home, a particular person, a particular environment, environmental cues like a room or a route. Once you can identify yours, and the context it shows up in, you can meet the loop at the door instead of discovering you are already inside it. A week of short notes on when the loops occur is usually enough to see the pattern. The point is to avoid the loop by seeing it coming, not to avoid the feeling.

Give rumination an appointment. Fifteen minutes at a set time, with a notebook, and then it waits until tomorrow. This sounds too simple to work. It works for many people, because the mind will often agree to wait when it knows it will get its turn. The choice is about when, not whether.

Practice the concrete mode on small things, daily, so it is available for big ones and rumination has less to work with. When the coffee spills, “what do I do now” instead of “why am I like this.” Change the question on the small stuff and the big stuff gets easier. With practice, the shift becomes less about controlling thoughts and more about choosing where attention goes.

Reduce the fuel for rumination. Short sleep, alcohol and other substance use, late-night scrolling, and the unfinished argument all make the loop louder the next day. None of them is the cause. All of them contribute, and the importance of sleep in particular is hard to overstate.

Build self-compassion as a skill, not a mood. The harsh voice in rumination is often an old one, and self-compassion is the practice of answering it the way you would answer a friend, and it leaves room for growth that the harsh voice never does. A mindfulness practice helps with rumination for a related reason: mindfulness meditation is practice at noticing where your attention has gone and bringing it back, which is the exact muscle rumination wears down. In a review of studies on how mindfulness programs work, a drop in rumination and worry was one of the main ways they improved well-being.

With a therapist

If rumination has been running for months, or it is about your worth rather than a task, the steps above will help and probably will not be enough on their own. That is what the next section is for.

How therapy helps with rumination

Psychotherapy for rumination is process focused: it works on the pattern, not just the content. You will talk about the thing you are stuck on, of course. The work is in learning to catch the loop earlier, understand what it is doing for you, and do something different, with practice between sessions.

Several forms of therapy do this well, and their methods differ. Their effectiveness is well documented, and no single one is the right choice for everyone. A good therapist will help you evaluate which fits you.

Therapy that targets the thinking style itself. A form of cognitive behavioral therapy built specifically for rumination, often called rumination-focused cognitive therapy, teaches you to notice the abstract “why” mode and disrupt it by shifting to the concrete “what” mode, over and over, until the shift becomes the new habit. In a small trial with adults whose residual depression had not fully lifted on medication, the researchers demonstrated that adding this therapy to usual care helped more people improve than usual care alone. The same approach, taught to teenagers and young adults who ruminated a lot, youth in a Dutch trial, lowered their chances of developing depression or an anxiety disorder over the following year. These are the interventions shown to significantly reduce rumination itself, not only the mood around it, in peer-reviewed studies in more than one country.

Mindfulness-based therapy. Learning to watch thoughts arrive and pass without climbing aboard, with acceptance rather than argument. As noted above, the drop in rumination is one of the main ways it works. In one study that followed 162 patients through therapy, the decrease in rumination was one of the clearest paths by which depression improved.

Therapy that changes what you believe about the thinking. That it helps. That it is uncontrollable. Changing those beliefs, rather than the thoughts themselves, is the focus of a newer approach with promising early results for depression.

Behavioral approaches. Scheduling activities and action so the loop has less room to run. Behavioral activation is a standard part of depression treatment, and a natural partner to the “today” routine above.

Understanding the loop helps, but education about it alone rarely stops it; practice does, and so does the next kind of work.

Depth-oriented therapy. The chance to gain insight into what the loop is doing for you, and what purpose it has served. In our work, rumination often turns out to be protection: it keeps a feeling at a distance, usually grief, shame, or anger, by keeping the mind busy with analysis. Protection has a price, and the price is rumination. Finding the feeling underneath, and discovering you can survive it, tends to quiet the analysis on its own. This is the slower road and, for many people, the one that lasts.

On medication: antidepressants treat depression and anxiety, and as mood lifts the loop often quiets with it. Medicine works on the mood. Rumination itself is a habit of thinking, and habits are what therapy works on. If you have a prescriber, both can run at once.

What sessions look like, in practice: you bring the thing you are stuck on. Your therapist helps you see the loop while it is running, in the room, and try the shift from “why” to “what” with someone beside you. Between sessions you practice on real moments. Over weeks, the loop gets shorter and starts later, and you get more of your evenings back, along with the sense that you can manage where your attention goes.

From Our Practice

People often expect therapy for rumination to be a search for the answer to the question they have been asking. It tends to go the other way. The question loses its grip once the feeling underneath it has somewhere to go, and that is usually the week the sleep comes back.

When to get help

Consider making contact with a mental health professional if the loop is running most days for two weeks or more, whether the onset was recent and tied to a specific event or has no clear start, if it is costing you sleep or showing up at work or in your relationships, if it is about your worth or whether you matter, or if it comes with hopelessness. You do not need to wait until it is unbearable. Earlier is easier, the issue responds well to help, and the possibility that the loop can get shorter is real hope rather than wishful thinking. It is what the research shows and what we see, and our depression and anxiety therapists work with this pattern every week.

If the thoughts include not wanting to be here, or hurting yourself, that is a different kind of urgent, and the steps above are not the answer. Call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, now. It is free, it is there at every hour, and it is for exactly this.

Talk to a therapist in Washington, DC about the loop

We will match you with the right therapist on our team, in person in Dupont Circle or online across DC, Maryland, and Virginia. Several of our psychologists also see clients by video in many other states.

References

The peer-reviewed literature this article draws on, from numerous studies conducted over three decades, including one prospective study that followed people for a year and various studies of how therapy works. Each is linked at the sentence it supports above, as opposed to being quoted without a source.

  1. Nolen-Hoeksema S. Responses to depression and their effects on the duration of depressive episodes. Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 1991;100(4):569-582.
  2. Nolen-Hoeksema S, Wisco BE, Lyubomirsky S. Rethinking rumination. Perspectives on Psychological Science. 2008;3(5):400-424.
  3. Treynor W, Gonzalez R, Nolen-Hoeksema S. Rumination reconsidered: a psychometric analysis. Cognitive Therapy and Research. 2003;27(3):247-259.
  4. Watkins ER. Constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought. Psychological Bulletin. 2008;134(2):163-206.
  5. Watkins ER, Roberts H. Reflecting on rumination: consequences, causes, mechanisms and treatment of rumination. Behaviour Research and Therapy. 2020;127:103573.
  6. Watkins ER, et al. Rumination-focused cognitive-behavioural therapy for residual depression: phase II randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry. 2011;199(4):317-322.
  7. Ehring T, Watkins ER. Repetitive negative thinking as a transdiagnostic process. International Journal of Cognitive Therapy. 2008;1(3):192-205.
  8. Michl LC, McLaughlin KA, Shepherd K, Nolen-Hoeksema S. Rumination as a mechanism linking stressful life events to symptoms of depression and anxiety: longitudinal evidence in early adolescents and adults. Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 2013;122(2):339-352.
  9. Johnson DP, Whisman MA. Gender differences in rumination: a meta-analysis. Personality and Individual Differences. 2013;55(4):367-374.
  10. Nolen-Hoeksema S. The role of rumination in depressive disorders and mixed anxiety/depressive symptoms. Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 2000;109(3):504-511.
  11. Hamilton JP, Farmer M, Fogelman P, Gotlib IH. Depressive rumination, the default-mode network, and the dark matter of clinical neuroscience. Biological Psychiatry. 2015;78(4):224-230.
  12. Thomsen DK, Mehlsen MY, Christensen S, Zachariae R. Rumination: relationship with negative mood and sleep quality. Personality and Individual Differences. 2003;34(7):1293-1301.
  13. Gu J, Strauss C, Bond R, Cavanagh K. How do mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and mindfulness-based stress reduction improve mental health and wellbeing? A systematic review and meta-analysis of mediation studies. Clin Psychol Rev. 2015;37:1-12.
  14. Topper M, Emmelkamp PMG, Watkins E, Ehring T. Prevention of anxiety disorders and depression by targeting excessive worry and rumination in adolescents and young adults: a randomized controlled trial. Behaviour Research and Therapy. 2017;90:123-136.
  15. Watkins E, Moulds ML, Mackintosh B. Comparisons between rumination and worry in a non-clinical population. Behaviour Research and Therapy. 2005;43(12):1577-1585.
  16. Sukhodolsky DG, Golub A, Cromwell EN. Development and validation of the Anger Rumination Scale. Personality and Individual Differences. 2001;31(5):689-700.
  17. Murray HB, et al. Diagnosis and treatment of rumination syndrome: a critical review. American Journal of Gastroenterology. 2019;114(4):562-578.
  18. O’Connor DB, O’Connor RC, Marshall R. Perfectionism and psychological distress: evidence of the mediating effects of rumination. European Journal of Personality. 2007;21(4):429-452.
  19. Smart LM, Peters JR, Baer RA. Development and validation of a measure of self-critical rumination. Assessment. 2016;23(3):321-332.
  20. Brosschot JF, Gerin W, Thayer JF. The perseverative cognition hypothesis: a review of worry, prolonged stress-related physiological activation, and health. Journal of Psychosomatic Research. 2006;60(2):113-124.
  21. Hagen R, Hjemdal O, Solem S, et al. Metacognitive therapy for depression in adults: a waiting list randomized controlled trial. Frontiers in Psychology. 2017;8:31.
  22. Pruessner L, Timm C, Kalmar J, et al. Emotion regulation as a mechanism of mindfulness in individual CBT for depression and anxiety disorders. Depression and Anxiety. 2024;2024(1):9081139.
  23. Miu AC, Szentágotai-Tătar A, Balázsi R, et al. Emotion regulation as mediator between childhood adversity and psychopathology: a meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Rev. 2022;93:102141.

Last updated: November 2026

This blog is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional mental health care. If you are in crisis, call or text 988.

FROM THERAPY GROUP OF DC
One of Our Core Specialties

Depression and Anxiety Therapy in Washington DC

Therapy for the loop and the low mood underneath it, in Dupont Circle and online across DC, Maryland, and Virginia.

Frequently Asked Questions
Replaying a conversation from work on the whole ride home, running it again at dinner, and again in bed, each time asking why you said what you said. The scene does not change and the question never gets an answer. Another common one is lying awake going over a breakup and looking for the moment it could have gone differently.
Overthinking is the everyday word for thinking too much, and it covers both worry and rumination. Rumination is the specific version that points backward, at something that already happened, and asks why. Worry points forward and asks what if. If you are not sure which you do, you probably do both, and the same tools help with each.
Usually several things at once. A stressful stretch or a loss gets it started. A habit of turning inward, often learned early, keeps it going. High standards, self-criticism, and low self-esteem give it material. And a belief, somewhere underneath, that the thinking is helping makes it hard to stop. No one of these is the whole cause.
In the moment, name it, change the question from why to what, and move your body. Over a day, write it down once and turn the problem into one small action. Over a month, learn when and where the loop starts and meet it there. If it has been running for months, or it is about your worth rather than a task, therapy is the step that usually makes the difference.
No. Rumination is a pattern of thinking, not a diagnosis, and most people do some of it. It shows up in depression, anxiety, OCD, trauma, and grief, and it makes those conditions worse. On its own it is a habit, which is a hopeful way to think about it, because habits can be changed.
Direction, mostly. Rumination looks back at losses and mistakes and asks why. Worry looks ahead and asks what if. Both are repetitive, both are negative, and many people do both. Researchers increasingly treat them as two sides of one thinking style, and the therapies that help with one tend to help with the other.
Because night removes everything else. During the day there are tasks, people, and screens to hold your attention. In bed there is nothing, and a mind that has learned to go inward goes inward. Tired brains are also worse at letting go of a thought. A set worry time earlier in the evening, a notebook by the bed, and getting up for a few minutes when the loop starts all help.
It can go with any of them, and it can also happen on its own. In depression it circles the past and the self. In anxiety it faces forward. In OCD it can become a mental ritual done to cancel a fear. People with ADHD often describe getting stuck on a thought too, partly because shifting attention is harder for them. The pattern is shared; what it is about, and what helps most, depends on the person.
Sometimes, when the stressful stretch ends. Often it does not, because by then it is a habit with its own schedule. The good news is that it responds well to being noticed and interrupted, and even better to therapy that works on the pattern directly. Most people who get help notice the loop getting shorter and starting later within weeks.
A different thing with the same name. Rumination disorder, also called rumination syndrome, is a digestive condition in which food comes back up after meals without nausea or effort. It is treated by doctors, often with breathing training. It has nothing to do with the thinking pattern this article is about.
50,000+ Monthly Readers · 169 Countries · Dupont Circle, Washington DC

Not sure where to start? Tell us what’s going on — it takes a few minutes.

Ready when you are.

Booking a first session is simple, and there’s no pressure to have it all figured out first.

Privacy Policy

Therapy Group of DC · Effective September 30, 2026

The short version

  • The only place this website collects personal information is the appointment scheduling assistant — and only what you choose to share there.
  • We use two analytics tools to understand what gets read: Google Analytics (which sets this site’s only cookies) and Ahrefs Analytics (which sets none). Google Analytics is linked to our Google Ads account so we can see whether any ads we run lead to appointment requests; ad personalization is off.
  • We don’t run social media pixels or remarketing, and we don’t sell your information or use it to target ads to you. There are no forms quietly collecting your details.
  • Questions, or want something corrected or deleted?

What this policy covers

This policy covers this website — therapygroupdc.com. It is not the privacy notice for therapy itself: if you become a client, your care is protected by federal and district health-privacy law, and you’ll receive our Notice of Privacy Practices as part of getting started. Nothing you read or click on this website creates a therapy relationship.

What we collect, and why

What you send us. If you email us, call us, or use the scheduling assistant (the “Make Appointment” button), we receive what you choose to share — typically your name, contact details, and what you’re looking for. We use it for exactly one purpose: responding to you and arranging care. The scheduling assistant is operated for us by WithTherapy, our scheduling provider, and the information you enter there goes to our practice and to the systems we use to manage appointments.

How the site gets used. Like most websites, we use analytics to understand which pages people read and where visitors come from — that’s how we decide what to write next. Google Analytics sets this site’s only cookies (named _ga and _ga_ZL758R38PL) and collects usage data such as pages visited, approximate location, and device type. Ahrefs Analytics collects similar aggregate usage data and sets no cookies at all.

Google Ads measurement. Our Google Analytics account is linked to our Google Ads account so we can see whether any ads we run lead to appointment requests. Because of that link, Google’s tag contacts Google’s advertising servers when a visit starts, which lets Google read a Google advertising cookie if your browser already has one; and when someone starts an appointment request, Google Analytics passes that event — not your name or contact details — to Google Ads. We have turned off ad personalization and Google’s signed-in-user matching (Google signals), and we don’t use any of this to build a profile of you or to show you ads elsewhere.

Accessibility preferences. The accessibility widget (accessiBe) lets you adjust how the site displays. If you use it, it stores your display preferences in your browser so they hold between visits.

What we don’t do

  • No social media pixels or buttons, and no advertising tags beyond the Google Ads link described above.
  • No remarketing — we will never follow you around the internet.
  • No selling or renting your information, ever, and no using it to target ads to you.
  • No comment forms, pop-up surveys, or newsletter capture.
  • Reading about a topic here tells us nothing about who you are — analytics reaches us as aggregate counts, not identified people.

The services behind the site

ServiceWhat it doesTheir policy
WithTherapyOperates the appointment scheduling assistantwiththerapy.com/privacy
Google Analytics 4Usage analytics, linked to our Google Ads account for ad measurement (ad personalization off)policies.google.com/privacy
Google AdsReceives appointment-request events from Google Analytics so we can measure our own ads; loads nothing on the site itselfpolicies.google.com/privacy
Ahrefs AnalyticsCookieless usage analyticsahrefs.com/legal/privacy-policy
accessiBeAccessibility widgetaccessibe.com/privacy-notice
VimeoPlays the video on our homepagevimeo.com/legal/privacy/policy
Google FontsDelivers the font for the scheduling button (loaded by the scheduling assistant)policies.google.com/privacy
CloudflareSecurity and content deliverycloudflare.com/privacypolicy
WP EngineHosts the websitewpengine.com/legal/privacy

Cookies

This site sets two cookies, both from Google Analytics (_ga, _ga_ZL758R38PL), used to distinguish visits in aggregate statistics. If you arrive here by clicking one of our Google ads, the same tag also stores two cookies (_gcl_aw, _gcl_gs) for up to 90 days recording that click, so the visit can be credited to the ad. Google’s advertising servers may also read a Google advertising cookie already set in your browser by other Google sites; this site doesn’t set one. You can block or delete them in your browser settings without affecting how the site works, or use Google’s opt-out browser add-on. If you use the accessibility widget, your display preferences are stored in your own browser, not sent to us.

Your choices and rights

You can browse this site without providing any personal information at all. If you have shared something with us — through the scheduling assistant, by email, or by phone — you can ask us what we hold, ask us to correct it, or ask us to delete it, by writing to . We’ll respond to reasonable requests promptly. Deletion requests may be limited where health-record or other law requires us to retain information.

Security and children

We use standard protections — encrypted connections (HTTPS) everywhere, and reputable providers for hosting and scheduling — and we limit what we collect in the first place, which is the best protection there is. This website is meant for adults and is not directed at children under 13; we don’t knowingly collect information from them.

Changes

When this policy changes, we’ll update it here and change the effective date at the top. We won’t quietly expand what we collect.

Who we are

District Psychotherapy Group PLLC (Therapy Group of DC)
1350 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 800
Washington, DC 20036 (USA)

Privacy contact: